As former collectors, we understand what it means to part with a prized possession. Since 1992, we’ve built a reputation of fairness, integrity and honesty. To get the ball rolling, please tell us about the collection you’re looking to sell.
Add to Your Collection
Your Local Sports Card Store
Serving the Greater Westchester, New York Area
Whether you are looking to sell sports cards or you are searching for something new and exciting to add to your collection, American Legends is your collectible sports cards superstore.
Shop our eBay store or visit us at our Westchester, NY location to check out our huge selection of new and rare cards, memorabilia, and more. From high-value cards and sets to new releases from today’s top sports card brands, we have something for every baseball, football, basketball, and hockey fan. Discover the vintage card your collection has been missing or pick up something unique for the sports lover in your life.
Looking to cash in your cards? We’ve earned our reputation as an honest, fair, and trustworthy sports card buyer since 1992. Our friendly team is full of former collectors, so we share your love of sports cards too!
Contact us or bring in your card collection for us to assess. We will take a close look at your cards and then give you a straightforward, no-hassle offer. We are most interested in buying singles, sets, and lots of pre-1975 sports cards. If you have just one special card or a whole room full, give us a call! We’re happy to take a look and make sure each card in your collection gets the attention it deserves.
Follow us on social media or join our email list for updates on new card releases, store events, and more.