American Legends

Where to Sell Baseball Cards

“The strongest thing baseball possesses today is its yesterdays."

Lawrence Ritter

Selling your collection

Turn Your Baseball Card Collection into Cash

“He’s (Mark Rubin) an honest guy. This is a tough hobby and there’s a lot of people out there who are not as reputable or kind…” Jack Miller

1969 TOPPS 500 MICKEY MANTLE

Are you thinking about where to sell baseball cards? Wondering what your collection is worth? Want to know how to get started? 

Contact us! We’ll make selling baseball cards straightforward and enjoyable for you.

American Legends is a trusted buyer of rare and vintage baseball cards in the Westchester County, New York and greater Northeast areas. We have been in business since 1992 and have a team of experts who can help you get the most value for your collection.

 

When you sell your baseball cards to American Legends:

  • You’ll get a competitive offer that maximizes the value of your baseball card collection. Our expert card buying team will evaluate your cards and give you a fair offer.
  • You’ll have a safe and secure selling experience. We have been in business for over 30 years and have a reputation for honesty and integrity. No hassles. No guessing. No worrying about the safety of the transaction.  
  • We make the selling process easy. We’ll handle the entire selling process for you, from evaluation to immediate payment.

How to Sell Your Baseball Cards

Once you’ve identified the cards you are interested in selling, just contact us to tell us more about your collection. You can expect a prompt response and honest answers.

Whether you want to sell a baseball card collection, a lot, or single cards, we are interested in hearing more about your baseball cards. Check out this list of what we’re most interested in buying right now.

1952 BOWMAN 218 WILLIE MAYSWhy Sell Your Baseball Card Collection to American Legends

Selling your baseball cards can be a tough decision. That’s why Mark Rubin of American Legends wants to make things simple for you. As a former collector himself, Mark knows how to treat your collection with respect.

With over 40 years of experience buying collections of all sizes, from $200 to more than $250,000, Mark has built a reputation for fairness, integrity, and honesty. 

In most cases, we’re looking to purchase pre-1975 baseball cards and memorabilia.
To learn more about selling a baseball card collection, fill out the form in the sidebar, OR just contact Mark Rubin at 914-725-2225 or via email at mark@amerlegends.com.

Sell Your Cards Today!

Ebay Store

"Set your goals high, and don't stop till you get there."

Bo Jackson