American Legends

Where to Sell Hockey Cards Cards

“The strongest thing baseball possesses today is its yesterdays."

Lawrence Ritter

Selling your collection

Get the Most Value for Your Hockey Cards

“He’s (Mark Rubin) an honest guy. This is a tough hobby and there’s a lot of people out there who are not as reputable or kind…” Jack Miller

where to sell hockey cards, sell hockey cardsWant to know where to sell hockey cards? Are you curious about what your hockey card collection is worth? 

Contact American Legends! Get the best value for your card collection with the most enjoyable and easy selling experience.

For over 30 years, American Legends has built a reputation as a fair, honest hockey card buyer. We’re located in Westchester County, NY and work with collectors across the greater New York area looking to sell sports cards.


When you sell your hockey card collection to American Legends, you get:

  • A fair, competitive offer that maximizes the value of your hockey card collection. We’ll give you a straightforward offer with no hassles and no surprises.
  • A secure, safe card selling transaction. We’re known as one of the most reputable sports card buyers in the Northeast for a reason–we’ve been in business for more than 30 years and always operate with honesty and integrity. 

A fun and simple card selling process. We make selling cards easy for you by managing all the steps, from evaluation to offer. If you decide to sell your cards to us, you can expect an immediate payment.

How to Sell Your Hockey Cards

To help you decide which hockey cards to sell, take a look at our list of what cards we want to buy right now. Don’t worry about the number of cards you want to sell as we buy entire collections, lots, and singles, including graded and ungraded cards. 

Contact us about your hockey card collection and we will promptly get back to you to learn more about your cards.

where to sell hockey cards, sell hockey cardsWhy Sell Your Hockey Cards to American Legends

As a former collector himself, Mark Rubin of American Legends understands how it can be a hard decision to part with your card collection. Mark has been buying and selling sports cards since 1978, including collections worth $200 to more than $250,000, and he’s known for integrity, fairness, and trustworthiness. 

Generally, we are interested in buying pre-1975 hockey cards and memorabilia.
To learn more about selling your collection, fill out the form in the sidebar, OR just contact Mark Rubin at 914-725-2225 or via email at mark@amerlegends.com.

Sell Your Cards Today!

Ebay Store

“Great moments are born from great opportunity.”

Herb Brooks